The phrase "that one didn't age well" has become a staple in pop culture, often used to critique how poorly something that was once praised now holds up over time. But what makes a once-beloved movie, TV show, or meme fall prey to this criticism?
In essence, a cultural phenomenon doesn't "age well" when it fails to stand the test of time. Elements like outdated humor, insensitive content, or plots that no longer resonate can contribute to this decline. Let's explore this concept in-depth, looking at factors that hasten or mitigate the effects of time on our favorite pieces of media.
Outdated References and Inappropriate Content
Many jokes and storylines that were once acceptable can now feel tone-deaf or even offensive. This shift often results from changes in societal norms and increased awareness of certain issues. For instance, comedy from decades past may rely heavily on stereotypes that aren't tolerated anymore.
Even if the intent wasn't malicious, jokes that punch down or target marginalized groups can 'age poorly.' As societal views evolve, we expect our entertainment to grow with us. When it doesn't, we start to view it as outdated or flat-out inappropriate.
Prevalent Cultural Gaffes
Some examples of 'aging poorly' come from movies and TV shows that contained cultural references or made assumptions that were acceptable at the time of release but fell out of favor later. Consider movies with problematic Native American stereotypes or jokes about mental health issues. Today, these may be seen as harmful and offensive, even if creators didn't intend it that way.
Public awareness of such issues has grown, leading to a reevaluation of how we consume and critique the entertainment we once loved.
Intolerance for Trope-heavy Plots
The overuse of certain narrative tropes or unrealistic plot devices can also contribute to a property 'aging poorly.' Audiences are more sophisticated and expect nuanced storytelling. Shows that over-rely on clichés, such as 'the mean girl' archetype in teen comedies, can feel tired and predictable with age.
As storytelling becomes more diverse and nuanced, we're less tolerant of flat, unoriginal characters or plotlines.
Lack of Timeless Themes or Universal Appeal
Some entertainment doesn't stand the test of time because it relied too heavily on trends or specific cultural moments. Without timeless themes or a broad appeal, these works can lose relevance quickly.
On the other hand, pieces that delve into universal human experiences or emotions often age gracefully. Take, for example, classic love stories or coming-of-age narratives that continue to resonate across generations.
Anchored by Trends
Shows or movies that were once popular because they captured the Zeitgeist can fall out of favor when the trends they chased move on. Unfortunately, these works may not have enough substance to keep viewers engaged once the initial ' buzz' fades.
Just look at pandemic-themed content. It's likely that many TV shows and films impressed upon the COVID-era will ' age poorly' because their stories are so tied to a specific, hopefully temporary, moment in time.
The Power of Relevance
Conversely, storytelling that draws from our shared human experiences remains relatable and compelling. Think of classic romantic comedies like "When Harry Met Sally" or dramas like "The Shawshank Redemption." Despite being decades old, they're still lauded today because they tackle themes that are universal and timeless.
As we continue to consume media and evaluate how it holds up over time, let's celebrate those pieces that stand the test of time while being critical of those that falter. After all, our collective awareness of what works and what doesn't influences how future content is created. And perhaps, in the process, we'll all become better storytellers.