◆Home Improvement Ideas Journal

Is Living in Staten Island Worth It?

By

When considering a new place to call home, the question "Is living in Staten Island worth it?"often arises. New York's often-overlooked borough is distinct in its urban-suburban blend, offering acabóadas and countryside that other boroughs can't match. Let's delve into the factors that make Staten Island a compelling choice for many.

Staten Island's unique selling proposition lies in its affordability, safety, and spacious living compared to its NYC counterparts. However, theaportability and're anecessary' public transportation might deter some. Let's explore these aspects to help you decide if living in Staten Island is worth it for you.

Affordability and Cost of Living

Staten Island is often referred to as the 'untapped gem' of New York City, largely due to its affordability. The median home price is significantly lower than Manhattan, Brooklyn, or Queens. According to NeighborhoodScout, homeownership is prevalent, with around 63% of residents owning their homes.

Is Staten Island Worth Visiting? (From A Local!)
Is Staten Island Worth Visiting? (From A Local!)
Staten Island Travel Guide 🗽 Best Things to Do, Zoo & Hidden Gems
Staten Island Travel Guide 🗽 Best Things to Do, Zoo & Hidden Gems
an aerial view of a city with lots of trees in the foreground and water in the background
an aerial view of a city with lots of trees in the foreground and water in the background

Renters also benefit from lower costs. ApartmentList reports that the median rent for a one-bedroom apartment is approximately $1,500, a significant saving compared to Manhattan's $3,970.

Taxes and Financial Incentives

New York State's School Tax Relief (STAR) program exempts eligible homeowners from paying school district taxes. Additionally, the state offers a property tax break for veterans. These incentives make homeownership more affordable for Staten Islanders.

Staten Island Ferry: Are the Views Worth it for Tourists?
Staten Island Ferry: Are the Views Worth it for Tourists?
there are many different pictures of the same city
there are many different pictures of the same city
the 15 best staten island attraction usa is featured in this postcard for an article
the 15 best staten island attraction usa is featured in this postcard for an article

Moreover, the borough's low sales tax (8%) and property tax rates (around 0.68% compared to Manhattan's 1.21%) further incentivize living here.

Safety and Quality of Life

Staten Island consistently ranks high in safety. According to trulia, it's the safest borough with violent and property crime rates well below the national average. This aspect significantly contributes to its high quality of life.

Green spaces, such as the 2,000-acre Greenbelt tubing system and historical sites like the Conference House Park, provide ample opportunities for outdoor recreation, adding to Staten Island's appeal.

there is a sign that says welcome to state island in front of a fenced area
there is a sign that says welcome to state island in front of a fenced area
Staten Island Neighborhood Businesses
Staten Island Neighborhood Businesses
This, is Staten Island
This, is Staten Island
Staten Island
Staten Island
Staten Island in New York: Is it worth a visit?
Staten Island in New York: Is it worth a visit?
The 5 Best Pizzas on Staten Island, NY
The 5 Best Pizzas on Staten Island, NY

Transportation and Commuting

While Staten Island offers a more peaceful pace than the city's core, its isolated location poses transport challenges. The Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge, the world's 10th-largest suspension bridge, is the main vehicle thoroughfare. However, with traffic congestion and hefty toll fees, driving might not be the most convenient option.

Public transportation, managed by the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA), is limited. The Staten Island Railway offers service to Manhattan, with express buses and the free Ferry service also available. However, these options might not be as frequent or extensive as those in other boroughs.

Car Dependence and Public Transportation

Living in Staten Island often necessitates owning a car. Despite the MTA's efforts to improve service, the low ridership in the borough presents challenges. The lack of viable alternatives may deter those unwilling to drive or rely heavily on public transport.

Staten Island Ferry - All You SHOULD Know Before Going 2026 (with Reviews)
Staten Island Ferry - All You SHOULD Know Before Going 2026 (with Reviews)
the city skyline is seen in the distance from an empty street with cars driving on it
the city skyline is seen in the distance from an empty street with cars driving on it
☾︎ sᴀʟᴇᴍᴀᴘᴘʀᴏᴠᴇs
☾︎ sᴀʟᴇᴍᴀᴘᴘʀᴏᴠᴇs
11 reasons why Staten Island is NYC's most underappreciated borough
11 reasons why Staten Island is NYC's most underappreciated borough
Staten Island
Staten Island
an aerial view of the city skyline and river
an aerial view of the city skyline and river
Staten Island 🇺🇸✨
Staten Island 🇺🇸✨
a welcome sign to staten island in the rain
a welcome sign to staten island in the rain
What's It Like To Live on Staten Island? 20 Things Only Us Natives Understand
What's It Like To Live on Staten Island? 20 Things Only Us Natives Understand
the welcome sign to state island, borough of parks
the welcome sign to state island, borough of parks
Raisa_Explore_NYC on Instagram: "This is how i get to Staten Island Enjoying the best views eveer!!! Send this to someone who would love this route🗽 it’s $4.50 actually #nyc #thingstodoinnyc #newyorkcity #nycrecs #thingstodoinny #nycinfluencer #views #bestviews #nycferry #statenisland" Best Views In Nyc, Navigating New York Highways, Travel Inspiration Nyc Night, New York City Pass Nyc, Staten Island, New York Travel, Travel Tips, Things To Do, New York
Raisa_Explore_NYC on Instagram: "This is how i get to Staten Island Enjoying the best views eveer!!! Send this to someone who would love this route🗽 it’s $4.50 actually #nyc #thingstodoinnyc #newyorkcity #nycrecs #thingstodoinny #nycinfluencer #views #bestviews #nycferry #statenisland" Best Views In Nyc, Navigating New York Highways, Travel Inspiration Nyc Night, New York City Pass Nyc, Staten Island, New York Travel, Travel Tips, Things To Do, New York
Staten Island, NY: Visiting Snug Harbor Cultural Center And Botanical Garden
Staten Island, NY: Visiting Snug Harbor Cultural Center And Botanical Garden
Todt Hill in Staten Island
Todt Hill in Staten Island
13 THINGS TO DO ON STATEN ISLAND YOU CAN’T MISS
13 THINGS TO DO ON STATEN ISLAND YOU CAN’T MISS

Conversely, others appreciate the reduced traffic congestion and parking ease compared to the city's core. Additionally, the free ferry service has replenished some of the accessibility to Manhattan and reduced commuting time for many residents.

Education and Employment Opportunities

Staten Island offers numerous educational institutions, notably the College of Staten Island (CUNY) and Wagner College. The borough's schools show improvements in performance, with numbers of students meeting standards rising.

Employment-wise, the aerospace, finance, and healthcare sectors contribute significantly to the borough's economy. The ongoing development of the North Shore Waterfront esplanade promises further growth, creating more opportunities for residents.

Economic Diversity and Growth

Staten Island's economy is diverse, encompassing industries like manufacturing, retail, and construction. The​ (SIEDC) and the borough's Industrial Development Agency (IDA) promote business and stimulate economic growth.

The revitalization of the North Shore, with projects like the New York Wheel and Empire Outlets, signals a promising future. These developments aim to create jobs, enhance tourism, and boost the local economy.

Diversity and Cultural Scene

Staten Island's cultural scene is flourishing, with numerous restaurants, museums, and artistic spaces. The Staten Island Museum, Snug Harbor Cultural Center & Botanical Garden, and the Alice Austen House Museum showcase the borough's rich history and diverse heritage.

The epicenter of Staten Island's vibrant food scene is the Arthur Kill Road strip, known for its mom-and-pop shops, pizzerias, and Italian bakeries. Neapolitan and New York-style pizzas reign supreme, with many considering Staten Island the Pie Capital of NYC.

Is living in Staten Island worth it? The answer largely depends on your priorities. If affordability, safety, and spacious living are high on your list, Staten Island could be your perfect fit. However, if you prefer quick access to NYC's countless opportunities and walkability, you might find living elsewhere more appealing. Ultimately, visiting Staten Island and experiencing its unique blend of urban and suburban charm firsthand can help you decide if it's the right place to call home.